Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe

Note: This is a user-generated website created for informational purposes, reviews, and feedback.

About Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe

Located on West Montrose Avenue in Chicago, IL, Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe is a renowned eatery with a rich history. Founded by Jimmy Kang, this establishment was originally situated in Lincoln Square, where it gained fame for its delectable New York-style pizza. Jimmy Kang was compelled to relocate his celebrated pizzeria from its two-story building in Lincoln Square. After nearly a year of searching for a new location while hoping to stay in Lincoln Square, Kang finally acquired the new spot on Montrose Avenue.

Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe is now thriving in its new location on West Montrose Avenue, still offering the same high-quality, wood-fired pizzas and a diverse menu of appetizers, salads, and pasta dishes. With a full-service bar featuring a variety of beers, wines, and coffee, it continues to be a beloved destination for locals and tourists alike. Experience the friendly ambiance, delicious fare, and affordable prices at Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe in its new home on West Montrose Avenue in Ravenswood.

Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe’s Menu

In the heart of Ravenswood on West Montrose Avenue in Chicago, IL, Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe takes pride in its exceptional menu offerings that showcase the finest, locally-sourced ingredients. With its recent relocation from Lincoln Square, this beloved eatery continues to deliver an array of delectable dishes that epitomize taste and quality. The standout feature of Jimmy’s menu is undoubtedly its New York-style pizzas, which are meticulously crafted with a perfect balance of fresh, high-quality ingredients.

The restaurant’s menu boasts a tantalizing selection of appetizers, salads, and pasta dishes, all prepared with the same commitment to quality. Whether you’re savoring the restaurant’s crispy wings or indulging in a hearty pasta, you can expect a harmonious blend of textures and flavors. At Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe on West Montrose Avenue, you’ll find a culinary experience that captures the essence of Ravenswood, a commitment to freshness and flavor that has been perfected in the restaurant’s new location.

See more

Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe’s Signature Dishes

Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe has gained widespread acclaim for its extensive and diverse menu, featuring a delectable array of dishes that have captured the hearts and taste buds of its patrons. From classic pizzas to mouthwatering pasta options and more, the restaurant offers a culinary journey that promises to satisfy every craving and palate.

White Pizza

White Pizza holds a special place in the hearts of many. This culinary masterpiece showcases the kitchen’s artistry, featuring a light and airy crust as its canvas. Upon this canvas, a velvety white sauce is generously spread, harmonizing with a generous layer of mozzarella cheese and a symphony of fresh herbs. The result is a rich and savory medley that leaves diners enchanted and yearning for another bite.

Pizza Slices

For those seeking a quick yet utterly satisfying bite, the Pizza Slices at Jimmy’s are a testament to simplicity done right. Each slice represents perfection with its thin, crisp crust adorned with a generous layer of cheese and sauce. Whether you opt for a classic pepperoni slice or delve into a veggie-loaded version, each bite offers a burst of flavor that is both convenient and mouthwatering.

White Pie

With garlic, ricotta cheese, mozzarella, and fresh basil as its star ingredients, this pizza is a tantalizing medley of textures and tastes. It exemplifies Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe’s commitment to crafting innovative and irresistible dishes that consistently draw patrons back for more. These beloved favorites are a testament to the culinary excellence and dedication to quality that define the dining experience at Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe.

Beverage Delights

Offering a diverse selection of fine beverages, Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe ensures a satisfying experience for those seeking the perfect drink to complement their meal. A thoughtfully curated assortment of beers, coffees, spirits, and wines is available, providing patrons with a range of options to elevate their dining experience. The beer selection consists of a variety of local and imported brews, allowing beer enthusiasts to explore different flavors and styles. Crafted with precision and care, these beers are chosen to complement the flavors of the cuisine. For coffee connoisseurs, Jimmy’s serves up a robust selection of coffee options, including specialty blends and single-origin beans.

Whether it’s an energizing espresso to kickstart the day or a smooth, aromatic coffee to savor alongside dessert, the cafe caters to all coffee preferences. Sip on a well-balanced selection of spirits and cocktails expertly crafted by skilled bartenders. Wine lovers will appreciate the carefully curated wine list, featuring both red and white varieties. From bold and robust reds to crisp and refreshing whites, the wines on offer provide a delightful accompaniment to the diverse menu options. With an extensive selection of beverages, Jimmy ensures that guests can find the perfect drink to enhance their dining experience, making it a go-to destination for those seeking a memorable culinary journey.

Cozy Dining Retreat

Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe offers a welcoming haven for those in search of a warm and inviting atmosphere. The space is thoughtfully designed to create a comfortable and stylish environment, making it an ideal spot to enjoy a meal or drinks with friends and family. The cafe’s interior exudes a sense of homeliness, with rustic elements and tasteful decor adding to its charm. Additionally, sports enthusiasts will find the cafe a fitting destination to catch the favorite games on screen while relishing delicious fare and drinks. Whether you’re seeking a cozy spot for a casual get-together or a stylish setting to enjoy sports events, Jimmy’s Pizza promises a comfortable and inviting experience for all.

Delivery at Your Fingertips

Conveniently catering to various dining preferences, Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe offers flexible options for customers. Whether you prefer to dine in, order takeout, or have your meal delivered, the choice is yours. Alternatively, if you prefer the comfort of your home, the delivery service ensures that your favorite pizza is just a few taps away on your preferred food delivery app. Utilizing popular third-party food delivery apps, you can easily browse a wide range of menu options, search for your favorite dishes, and take advantage of the exclusive app coupon to enjoy delicious pizzas at a discounted price. Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe is committed to making your dining experience as convenient and delightful as possible, no matter how you choose to enjoy the delectable fare.

Make sure to use Doordash, Seamless. Grubhub, Uber Eats, Trycaviar, and Postmates to order your food today!

Customer Reviews

Share your thoughts on your Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe experience using the website’s feedback form. Your reviews provide an impartial viewpoint of this establishment, helping other customers make well-informed choices. Even if you haven’t visited Jimmy’s Pizza yet, you can still benefit from the feedback of others. Your input contributes to a valuable resource for the community.

Discover More

Super crispy, great sauce, crust was light, and great cheese

September 21, 2023

As a huge pizza fan, finally visiting Jimmy’s was incredibly exciting. The interior is impressively spacious, the selection of pizza slices is a dream, and the dine-in area offers plenty of room. My first impression of the inside was fantastic.

Now, onto the pizza – it was truly delightful. I couldn’t resist and ended up getting multiple slices to go. I always start with a cheese slice to judge the quality, and it did not disappoint. It was super crispy with a great sauce, light crust, and excellent cheese.

I also tried the burrata/pepperoni, hot honey, and Margherita slices, and each had its own unique deliciousness. I brought my mom along, and she opted for a very unique slice – goat cheese, arugula, and balsamic glaze. Normally, I’m not a fan of “veggie” slices, but this one was incredibly fresh, and all the flavors worked together beautifully.

To top it off, the cashier who took my order was incredibly kind, adding even more to the already great experience. If you’re craving thin slice pizza, make sure to visit here and savor every bite!

Avatar for Will J.
Will J.

Hands down the best New York slice that Chicago has to offer

September 20, 2023

I stopped by for a quick slice before heading to the movies, and wow, it was incredibly delicious. They have an extensive display of unique flavor combinations, and it was a tough choice. I didn’t want to get too full before the movie, so I settled for just one slice, but next time, I’ll definitely be trying a few different ones.

I opted for a classic pepperoni slice, and it came out piping hot with gooey cheese and crispy pepperoni. Every bite was bursting with flavor. The fresh and robust tomato sauce, along with the crispy crust, made for a perfect slice. Unlike some New York-style pizza, these slices didn’t flop around, which was a plus. I was also intrigued by their Quattro funghi truffle pizza – who wouldn’t be? Four types of mushrooms and truffle oil? I’ll have to give it a try next time.

Avatar for Misa T.
Misa T.

I've been a fan of Jimmy's pizza since they first opened on foster and Lincoln

September 18, 2023

My husband and I were regulars at their smaller to-go location, enjoying their fantastic New York-style pizza almost every week. In our opinion, it’s the best New York-style pizza you can find in Chicago, even rivaling some places in NYC. We also loved their beignets, although we’re not sure if they still serve them at the new location.

The new place offers plenty of options and has a much larger kitchen and seating area, along with a wider selection of alcoholic beverages. The servers were friendly, and we’re definitely looking forward to returning for a dine-in experience.

Avatar for Krisanne I.
Krisanne I.

They have a pick up counter that is always very organized and busy

September 12, 2023

This place could easily have the best New York-style pizza in the city. The slices are enormous, and the whole pies are outstanding. They offer an impressive array of pizza combinations, and you should definitely explore them all. While you can grab a slice, I’d recommend getting a couple of whole pies if you’re dining with a large group. Their pickup counter is consistently well-organized and bustling. Don’t forget to try the white pizza with hot honey on the side – it’s a flavor explosion!

Avatar for Ian M.
Ian M.

Jimmy's Pizza Cafe is added to the rotation especially for their NY Style pizza

September 1, 2023

Please be cautious as there are several steps near the front door and by the booths. It’s easy to miss them if you’re not paying attention or have had a bit too much to drink – but hey, no harm done! I won’t deduct any stars for the almost mishap because the NY-style pizza here is absolutely fantastic! The crust is deliciously crispy, and the toppings are fresh and flavorful. Don’t miss the spicy goose slice for a unique twist, but the classic sausage and pepperoni options are also excellent. I also tried the vegetarian slice, which was refreshing and packed with juicy goodness, without being mushy. The pizza alone would have made me happy, but they also offer a great selection of beer and a cozy fireplace to complete the experience!

Avatar for Randy W.
Randy W.

For a thorough analysis, consult the Tripadvisor and Yelp reviews!

Contact Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe

Visiting Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe is a must for anyone looking to indulge in delectable New York-style pizza and a diverse menu of mouth watering options. Join and savor the flavors of wood-fired pizzas, along with a wide selection of appetizers, salads, and a thoughtfully curated beverage menu. Discover the warm and friendly atmosphere that has made this place a favorite among both locals and visitors. The restaurant looks forward to serving you and ensuring that your visit to Jimmy’s Pizza is a memorable one. To find the restaurant, simply access the map below, which will guide you to the precise location in the heart of the city. Come and explore the culinary delights, and let Jimmy be part of your dining experience.